Audit log if messages are deleted
I agree with the stance it's the user's right to delete their message and have it be deleted, I think it should be logged that a message was in fact deleted, in what channel, by who, and who's message. With reasons. This would allow you to see if a mod is deleting tons of messages for no reason quietly, or if you swear you saw something suspicious and you think it got deleted, you can check that. No message content needed.
We are considering adding deletes by non-bots. As bots do it at high velocity and will break the audit log.
As an admin to a few discords with members who like to get in squabbles and then delete their stuff, I'd really like to see a log of who deleted a message, what it contained, and in what context it originally was. I find my ability to get to the bottom of what happened is diminished when half the conversation is in pieces.
The Architect commented
i think it should log what the message said
We really need this in the audit file, at least for a temporary time like 48 hours before official deletion.
This is possible through bots already, but would be better with official support.
Audit log should display contents of deleted messages
If someone wants to delete things arbitrarily and then invent reasons for why it was done, it is impossible to argue against when nobody else can verify the post's contents.
It's shockingly easy to abuse.
I have been an admin on a couple servers where someone has said something, than they delete the post a day later, than they say: When did I say this? It's not in chat!! Than I hate them...
I love discord so much, but it doesn't log when players delete their own messages. I get that bots could spam the log, but at least have it so when users delete their own messages, it shows up in the logs. That would be great!
we need that, but not with the bots, just make it so that bot deletiong gets put in a different log!
When a message is deleted, show what that message contained inside the audit logs. This would help prevent abusive deletion.
Marius Alcadius commented
just an idea but as an admin for multiple servers and a couple large ones at that. It's come to our attention that when it comes to incidents where messages are deleted. we can't see what the message said in the audit log so when we try to find out what happened, why it was deleted and what needs to be one, we have no evidence but what the person who deleted the message says. so more often than not we end up in a situation where we don't know the whole story. So i believe it would be very helpful if admin could read the deleted messages in the audit log as it would help solve disputes and end confusion at a faster and more reliable speed
It would be nice to being able, as an admisitrator or as the channel owner, to visualize messages that have been deleted by the same person who has posted it, to avoid people to hide foul/against the rules messages behind the fact nor them nor messages don't appear in the audit log.
"Might I also suggest that the audit log also keep a copy of the message that was deleted, to be displayed when clicked. When people complain that a message broke the rules, and we go to check, but the message has been deleted, knowing that the message has been deleted in the audit log doesn't help us if we don't know what that message said.
Usually I suggest that people screenshot messages like that, but that's not always going to be an option. I also have a situation currently, where a user was causing trouble and I forgot to take a screenshot. You can see in the audit log that I deleted four of this users messages, but no one can see what these messages were. " -Andy - The Priest of Gamers
I agree with this 100%
My current problem is. I am running a discord for my Twitch. I can see messages my mods deleted but I need to know what they were. I have to keep tabs on them especially the newer ones, they might have deleted something that was acceptable.
Twitch is a business and this has the potential to cost me viewers and money, money which does go towards Discord Nitro.
Twitch Support has responded that it will get added to their server feature. Sadly I would 100% leave discord and start using their app if it gets added. In fact I have already started creating all the rooms and voice channels, just in case. In the end it will likely be a backup for if discord ever goes down. Unless they this feature and other features that focus on complete control of my server.
If this was a business application this wouldn't have been overlooked. I understand it takes up space to log messages.
Here is how to solve it:
You Can make it a Nitro feature with or without an expiration
You Can make us select a Drive to save Audit Logs client side
You Can make it so that it expires after 72 hours
You Can store it in a client side Cached folder and seamlessly integrate it, a la millenial "do it for me cause it's too hard" style :D
---No this is not my streaming account. I don't need the spam that usually ensues, there's twitter for that---
I know that when a moderator deletes the message from another user, the action appears in the Audit Log, but the message itself does not appear. Sometimes it is helpful to know what the message that was deleted was saying. And also show when a user deletes their own message, which is very important, if it is a NSFW post, or something against the server rule. These things would be very useful for staff members. Thanks for your time!
if there was an option to see whats deleted that would be great in one of my servers we have an admin under review for deleting random messages but we have no way to check to see exactly what messages were deleted or restore them
I know its a big ask but I feel it would be helpful if server admins could look at what has been deleted in the Audit Log and not just that something was deleted and who it was deleted by to allow admins to have greater control over what happens on the server.
Add the functionality to view the message(s) the was deleted.
Get a modbot that logs deleted messages since Discord's servers don't save deleted messages and once they're deleted, they're gone for good.
Captain | xTuttlex56 commented
It Would Be Very Useful To Have Chat Logs For Monitoring A Server, A Common Issue Im Facing Is Going Offline And Coming Back To People Breaking Rules & Then Deleting Their Messages, It Would Be Very Useful To Be Able To Go Back And View Messages Whenever Needed
Andy - The Priest of Gamers commented
Might I also suggest that the audit log also keep a copy of the message that was deleted, to be displayed when clicked. When people complain that a message broke the rules, and we go to check, but the message has been deleted, knowing that the message has been deleted in the audit log doesn't help us if we don't know what that message said.
Usually I suggest that people screenshot messages like that, but that's not always going to be an option. I also have a situation currently, where a user was causing trouble and I forgot to take a screenshot. You can see in the audit log that I deleted four of this users messages, but no one can see what these messages were.
I agree with Tuna. Perhaps having deleted and self-deleted messages separate?
There's been a problem in some servers I'm in where people are posting messages that break the server/discord rules, then they delete them soon after. Admins can't see in the audit log when people delete their own messages, so there's no proof to mute/ban the person. If we had a section in the audit log for people deleting their own messages, it'd be really helpful for cases like these. Also having an option to not show this in the audit log might helpful too, since there would be a lot of people deleting their own messages for non-malicious reasons.